How to Ship Valuable Cards Without Damaging Them

We see shipping damage every week. Cards that arrive with new bends, corner dings, or surface impressions that weren't in the original photos. Almost all of it is preventable.

The standard we use for every incoming card

1. Perfect-fit inner sleeve Go on first, directly over the card. These eliminate movement inside the outer sleeve and protect against dust and surface contact.

2. Standard penny sleeve over the inner This adds a second layer of surface protection and makes the card easier to handle without touching the inner sleeve.

3. Rigid toploader Use a standard 35pt toploader for most cards. Thicker cards (Pokemon E-series, some older sets) need 55pt or 75pt. The card should fit snugly — not loose, not forced.

4. Tape the toploader shut A small piece of painter's tape across the open end of the toploader prevents the card from sliding out on impact. Don't use regular tape directly on the sleeve.

5. Two toploaders back-to-back Place a second empty toploader behind the first, opening facing away. This doubles the rigidity and prevents the card from being bent if the package is compressed.

6. Bubble wrap — two layers Wrap the toploader sandwich in bubble wrap. Tape it closed. Then wrap again. You want at least 1 inch of cushion on every side.

7. Rigid box, not a padded envelope This is non-negotiable for anything over $50. A rigid card box, USPS small flat-rate box, or similar. Padded envelopes compress under pressure and flex — that flex transfers to your card.

8. Insurance Declare the full replacement value. USPS and UPS both offer easy online insurance. If the card is worth grading, it's worth insuring.

When you accept a quote through our platform, we'll send you a shipping address. Choose your preferred shipping method and we will update you when it arrives.